Repository navigation
Conversation
Mashin6
commented
Nov 13, 2026
- Added new imagery from 2016
- fixed wms url for hillshade layer 2023
|
You should drop 2016. It was already excluded from years ago. |
|
2016 CT ECO service is still running and tiles are being served. Why is it problematic to have it included? |
cicku
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Just because there is a layer running doesn't mean we need to include it.
Especially we have 2019 and 2023 already included. There is 0 value of the one from 2016.
|
I still don't understand what harm does this layer bring. There are many such cases for other areas. E.g. Berlin has imagery for every year from 2026 to 2017. The value is that some structures are better seen though tree canopies in 2016 and some in 2023 imagery. And it helps to determine if OSM object is a remnant from 2016 and now is demolished, or if it's something new that is not captured on the 2023 imagery yet. |
|
I don't usually review European submissions, they have their own rules. Berlin and some European places may have old imageries because they captured the whole countries through multiple years due to funding issues. For USA, the included layers are mostly statewide or county imageries of the last 3 cycles. Anything older beyond should not be included unless you have a perfect reason (like WV has an imagery composite with certain areas dating back to 10-15 years ago, but it is mostly mountains), because many imagery program receives updates in 4-6 years.
That's not a reason I will agree with. You can easily use Bing or ESRI to verify if there are old objects on the map, in fact none of them are still with 2016 in CT. Unless there is a substantial amount of areas looking better in 2016 (which is false because I committed the first ECO imagery back to 2021/2022), I won't give you a pass then. The main consumer of this index is always the ID project - backporting old imageries will open a can of worms, like vandalism. For an affluent state like CT, publishing new imageries every 2-3 years is almost guaranteed. If you want to map or examine building footprints, the first thing you should consider is the 2D footprints from the state, generated from the LiDAR: |